The Cowboys had five sacks on Brock Purdy, scored 40 points, and still couldn’t find a way to beat the San Francisco 49ers. Dallas allowed 584 yards of offense in the 46-40 loss, with 340 of those yards coming in the second half.
For much of the first half, Dallas looked capable of competing with San Francisco. The defensive line was getting pressure, and Dak Prescott was finding George Pickens downfield. But once Kyle Shanahan started getting his playmakers into space, the Cowboys had few answers.
The biggest problem wasn’t necessarily what San Francisco was doing offensively. You’re going to give up plays against Shanahan, Christian McCaffrey and George Kittle. But the missed tackles, blown assignments and questionable defensive calls turned what should have been manageable situations into explosive plays.
And when Brock Purdy was able to escape pressure, he made Dallas pay.
What Happened
For much of the first half, Dallas looked capable of competing with one of the NFC’s best teams.
Dak Prescott connected with George Pickens for two touchdowns, helping Dallas build a 16-10 lead. But a 74-yard touchdown reception by Christian McCaffrey gave San Francisco a 17-16 halftime advantage.
Things unraveled after halftime.
San Francisco scored 21 unanswered points and eventually built a 38-19 lead. Dallas fought back behind Prescott and Pickens, but McCaffrey’s 66-yard touchdown reception effectively ended the comeback.
The loss dropped Dallas to 4-6.
Purdy and Shanahan Were Simply Better
The Cowboys actually had success pressuring Brock Purdy, recording five sacks. But generating pressure and stopping an offense are two different things.
Purdy finished 22-of-28 for 389 yards and three touchdowns, posting a 154.5 passer rating.
What impressed me most was his ability to improvise. Even when Dallas disrupted the original play, Purdy extended possessions, read coverage after the snap and found opportunities downfield.
And Kyle Shanahan consistently put his players in favorable situations.
San Francisco averaged 9.4 yards per play, with McCaffrey, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel all creating problems.
One particularly questionable defensive decision came on an all-out blitz that left Von Miller responsible for covering McCaffrey.
Miller defended the call afterward, but that doesn’t change the matchup. Asking an edge rusher to cover one of football’s most dangerous receiving backs is a difficult assignment.
Shanahan took advantage.
The Mistakes That Cost Dallas
Here’s what makes this loss especially frustrating: Dallas made defensive plays that should have mattered.
The Cowboys recorded five sacks, but positive plays were repeatedly overshadowed by penalties, missed tackles and explosive gains.
One potential sack was erased by defensive holding, giving San Francisco another opportunity.
According to Next Gen Stats, Dallas missed 10 tackles that resulted in 91 additional yards.
That’s unacceptable against an offense already capable of creating explosive plays. The 49ers finished with 214 rushing yards, including Samuel’s 70-yard touchdown reverse. Dallas struggled with pursuit angles, maintaining assignments and finishing tackles.
Where Do the Cowboys Stand in the Playoff Race?
At 4-6, the Cowboys’ playoff hopes aren’t completely gone, but they’re certainly running out of room for error.
The good news? The NFC East is still very much up for grabs. The New York Giants lead the division at 5-3-1, despite losing to Washington on Thursday night. Dallas had an opportunity to gain ground Sunday but couldn’t take advantage.
According to The Athletic’s playoff simulator, the Cowboys still have a 28% chance of winning the NFC East. And with the Giants facing a difficult stretch of games, there are opportunities for Dallas to close the gap.
The problem is that the Cowboys have to start winning football games. With seven games remaining, Dallas likely needs at least five wins to give itself a realistic chance.
The division is giving the Cowboys every opportunity to stay in the race. Whether Dallas can actually take advantage is another question.
NFC East: Next Four Weeks
Standings as of November 17, 2026 | Weeks 11–14
| Team | Record | Week 11 | Week 12 | Week 13 | Week 14 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NY Giants | 5-3-1 | vs. Jaguars | @ Colts | vs. 49ers | @ Seahawks |
| Dallas Cowboys | 4-6 | vs. Titans | vs. Eagles | @ Seahawks | BYE |
| WAS | 3-5-1 | vs. Bengals | @ Cardinals | @ Titans | vs. Texans |
| Philly | 2-7 | vs. Steelers | @ Cowboys | @ Cardinals | vs. Colts |
Home games marked “vs.”; road games marked “@”. Records are current, not projected. NFL+1
The Giants have a particularly difficult stretch coming up, facing the 49ers and Seahawks in consecutive weeks. Dallas, meanwhile, gets Tennessee and Philadelphia at home before traveling to Seattle and entering its bye week.
The Cowboys have an opportunity to close the gap, but they need to take advantage of those next two home games. Dallas also hosts the Giants on January 3, a matchup that could carry significant NFC East implications.
The problem is that New York has the tie with the Commanders, meaning they will always have a .5 game advantage if Dallas and NY have the same amount of losses.

Leave a Reply